Logo

Biggest Upsets in Super Bowl History: Underdogs Who Won

Biggest Upsets in Super Bowl History: Underdogs Who Won

Everyone loves an underdog. Some of the greatest moments in Super Bowl history came from teams that almost nobody expected to win, and the oddsmakers agreed.

Here are the five biggest Super Bowl upsets ever, ranked by how big an underdog each winner was going into the game.

How "Biggest Upset" Is Measured

The usual yardstick is the point spread: how many points the favourite was expected to win by. The bigger the spread, the bigger the shock when the underdog wins. New to spreads? Our guide on how to read NFL odds explains it in plain English.

The Five Biggest Super Bowl Upsets

RankSuper BowlUnderdogFavouriteSpreadFinal
1III (1969)New York JetsBaltimore Colts18Jets 16–7
2XXXVI (2002)New England PatriotsSt. Louis Rams14Patriots 20–17
3XLII (2008)New York GiantsNew England Patriots12.5Giants 17–14
4IV (1970)Kansas City ChiefsMinnesota Vikings12Chiefs 23–7
5XXXII (1998)Denver BroncosGreen Bay Packers11.5Broncos 31–24

1. Super Bowl III: The Guarantee

The AFL's New York Jets were 18-point underdogs against the NFL's Baltimore Colts, and many thought the younger league didn't belong on the same field. Jets quarterback Joe Namath publicly guaranteed a win anyway. The Jets won 16–7, and it remains the biggest Super Bowl upset by point spread.

2. Super Bowl XXXVI: A Dynasty Begins

The St. Louis Rams' "Greatest Show on Turf" offence was a 14-point favourite. A young Tom Brady led the Patriots on a late drive to set up a game-winning field goal as time expired, the first of the franchise's six titles.

3. Super Bowl XLII: Perfection Denied

The 2007 Patriots were 18–0 and one win away from the first 19–0 season in NFL history. The New York Giants, 12.5-point underdogs, won 17–14, helped by David Tyree's famous helmet catch and a late touchdown from Plaxico Burress.

4. Super Bowl IV: Proof It Wasn't a Fluke

A year after the Jets' win, many still doubted the AFL. The Kansas City Chiefs, 12-point underdogs, dominated the Minnesota Vikings 23–7 in the last Super Bowl before the two leagues fully merged.

5. Super Bowl XXXII: Elway's Moment

The defending champion Packers were 11.5-point favourites. Running back Terrell Davis scored three touchdowns, and John Elway's famous "helicopter" run helped Denver win 31–24 for his first Super Bowl title.

What These Upsets Have in Common

  • Defence travels: most of these underdogs held a high-powered offence well below its average.
  • Belief matters: from Namath's guarantee to a young Brady, confidence played a big part.
  • Odds are expectations, not certainties. The favourite doesn't always win, which is what makes sport worth watching.

That last point applies everywhere. In a casino too, results are random and nothing is ever guaranteed. Read 10 online gambling myths debunked.

Could Super Bowl LXI Bring Another Shock?

This season has already produced plenty of surprises. Will the favourite win in February, or will an underdog write a new chapter? Make your call in The Platinum Playbook at Platinum Reels:

  • Free Championship Call: pick the Super Bowl LXI winner. Correct predictors share $50,000 in casino rewards. One pick per account; entries close 13 February 2027.
  • Game Day Picks: back an underdog with your leaderboard points (not money). Right doubles your points; wrong loses the points staked.
  • $100,000 monthly leaderboards right through to the Super Bowl.

See how The Platinum Playbook works.

FAQ

What is the biggest upset in Super Bowl history?

Super Bowl III in 1969, when the New York Jets beat the Baltimore Colts 16–7 as 18-point underdogs.

Who beat the undefeated Patriots in the Super Bowl?

The New York Giants, 17–14, in Super Bowl XLII. The Patriots had gone 18–0 that season.

What was Tom Brady's first Super Bowl win?

Super Bowl XXXVI, when the Patriots beat the St. Louis Rams 20–17 as 14-point underdogs.

Do underdogs often win the Super Bowl?

Favourites have won more often, but underdogs have produced many of the game's most famous moments.

Root for the Underdog

The next great upset could be just weeks away. Make your free Super Bowl call before 13 February.

Make your Championship Call

Players must be 21 or older. Please play responsibly. Platinum Reels is not affiliated with the NFL and does not offer sports betting.